A Pencil Can Be Erased
Return to Main Newsletter Page

       If a fountain pen doesn't perform its job, a pencil will do. In fact, the lowly yellow pencil has several advantages. Besides being inexpensive, it never skips, never floods, and except for sharpening, doesn't require maintenance. It can be erased. Also, pencil marks last almost forever. On the other hand, fountain pen ink can be fugitive, not particularly light fast - especially colors on the warm side of the palette, red, yellow and orange.
       So just what are the properties of a fountain pen that makes it worth the effort?
       I know writers who say they prefer a fountain pen for the first draft, especially for thoughtful writing such as poetry or establishing the outline of a book or article. They tell me it has to do with the connection between the hand and the mind. Their thoughts flow more easily with a wet nib. The common metaphor, "the flow of thoughts" points up the comparison with writing using a fountain pen. When a fountain pen is adjusted properly, it requires no pressure. The ink runs onto the paper as the nib glides over the surface. (A pencil is hardly legible when used this way.
       I find it a big advantage, when I go back to typing words onto a keyboard, to be able to read what I have written. For those of us with aging eyes, this is even more important.


Marginalia
       Several writers have told me that they need a pen for marginalia, the notes, corrections and new ideas that are edited into a previously written document. The requirements for this sort of nib can be stringent, because of limited space in the margins. A fine or extra-fine point is works the best. And although it should write dryly, it should be smooth. We have found the Japanese Namiki and Sailor brands are the best suited. The Namiki fine is finer than any fine points made by American or European manufacturers and the Sailor extra-fine is the finest of them all. Both have extremely good ink flow characteristics, meeting the requirements of an editor.
       So many new ink colors are now available. Besides being fun, color is useful. If a document is to receive several edits, the use of several colors will eliminate confusion. If several people make successive edits of the same document, it is possible, if they have used different colors, to easily see who made them and what they said. I like green or red for editing because I rarely use these colors on a first drafts.
John Mottishaw, August 2004